Vic Firth came up with the idea of making a better drumstick while playing timpani for the Boston Symphony Orchestra. The sticks he could buy commercially didn’t measure up to the job so he began making and selling drumsticks from his basement at home. Then one day he dropped a bunch of sticks on the floor and heard all the different pitches. That’s when he began to match up sticks by moisture content, weight, density, and pitch so they were identical pairs. The result became his product’s tag line: “the perfect pair.” Today, Vic Firth’s factory turns out over 85,000 drumsticks a day and has a 62 percent share in the drumstick market.
Les Paul invented the solid body guitar because his audience at a BBQ joint couldn’t hear him play.
I was appearing in person playing outdoors at a place called Goerke’s Corner. That was halfway between Waukesha and Milwaukee, and it was interesting because the people would drive in to get their barbecue sandwiches and their root beer, or whatever. I would play and sing for them, and one fellow sitting in a rumble seat of a car wrote a note to me and gave it to the car hop. She brought it to me and it says, “What you got going up there…I can hear your voice and your harmonica fine and I enjoy it, but the guitar is not loud enough.” That made me go home and think about it, and in my own simple way, I said, “Well, now, let me investigate the guitar.” I first tried filling it up with rags, and I ended up with Plaster of Paris in it.
Alain Mongeau, Mutek’s founder and director, explains how Robert Henke came up with Ableton Live:
An artist like Monolake [techno producer and sound artist Robert Henke] is a perfect example. For instance, he’s always wanted to make the kind of music that he was imagining, but there was no way to make it happen. So he actually pushed and pushed and pushed and finally created the tools to make that music, which ended up being Ableton Live software, something that’s obviously had a tremendous impact on this whole field in the last ten years.
These musicians had a problem. They went out and solved it. And it turns out there were tons of other people out there who wanted the same solution.
We associate great ideas with lightning strikes. But the truth is a lot of great inventions come from dull aches. What’s hurting you? And how can you fix it? There might be a big crowd out there who wants that solution too.
Luke
on 01 May 09Great write-up and food for thought. This just confirms the old, Plato adage:
Necessity is the mother of invention
Sometimes our needs are just little things, but a usable, innovative solution to the shared need of many people definitely has market potential.
Dave
on 01 May 09I’m sure a lot of the software we use today is born from similar stories…
“I’ll make this thing for myself because there’s nothing out there that does exactly what I want…”
A couple years later we have Wikepedia or Basecamp or Google, etc…
Michael Riley
on 02 May 09@Luke Absolutely love that quote, it’s totally true. The best inventions are the ones that come about because of necessity.
Sarssipius
on 02 May 09Nice article and examples of how things should always be done…
John Gallagher
on 02 May 09Fantastic post. I’ve just started my own journey on making something I’ve needed for 5 years.
One barrier for me, and I think many other people, is not the idea but the confidence that you can actually make something yourself that is better than current solutions. That you have the dedication to follow through and implement your idea, especially when it’s pretty ambitious. It’s one thing to have an idea for how things can be better, it’s a whole other thing when you have to put some degree of faith in yourself to take action.
I’m still not sure I can pull off my idea, but it’s my dream to do it and I’ve got a bit of money to power me through, so I’m giving it a bash. I’d encourage others to do the same as I have a funny feeling that even if I fail miserably at least I won’t be saying “if only…” for the rest of my life.
Billee D.
on 03 May 09Great post and I recently chirped-in on Twitter to someone who was thinking along the same lines about “rolling your own” CMS in Rails. My experiences have been great so far and the more I learn about the framework the better my solutions tend to be.
Necessity is the mother of invention, but constraint is the mother of design. A lot of commercial or free software may not always be the right fit for every task. Being able to build your own solution is not only rewarding, but may also be the only way to get what you really need.
Thanks for the read!
John Self
on 03 May 09Great back story about Vic Firth drum sticks… I’ve used them for many years. I discovered a while ago that they also make pepper grinders that are equally well made. Makes me wonder which came first, the sticks or the grinders!
ArcDuke
on 03 May 09I loved this story from a few years ago about the opposite kind of invention, one that fits no quantifiable need, yet still requires much effort to complete. This fella wouldn’t rest until he’d invented colored disappearing bubbles [popsci.com].
Tim Walker
on 04 May 09Love this. Similar story in a different field: Dr. Michael DeBakey had the idea for open-heart surgery before the heart-lung pump existed . . . so he invented the heart-lung pump.
Luís Fernando Bicudo
on 05 May 09Necessity is the mother of invention.
But creativity, its father. :-)
Nice post.
Peter Connor
on 07 May 09A year ago I got stuck with the bill for a tag rugby team, caught with with in awkward reminds and debt collecting. So I built SplitMyBil.iel on less than 5k while I was holding another job down.
We decided to take that thinking into our charity StreetSmart aswell (which we run on the side too). One day I had to dump the Christmas tree and spent a day hoovering the pine needles out of my car. Out of that itch ‘the Christmas tree bag’ was born. All profits going to our charity. Simple As.
Pete
skier
on 07 May 09Drumsticks are like skis….high-end nordic racing skis are all individually flex-tested and paired, calibrated within a couple of kg to the skier’s weight.
Giles Bowkett
on 08 May 09Shameless self-promotion, this is what inspired my Ruby music library Archaeopteryx as well, and here’s an mp3 of a track I made with it last night. Nothing to that track but some stock loops and Archaeopteryx generating original drum rhythms. I wanted a way to make my drums more interesting, so I created Archaeopteryx. The drums in the mp3 switch their pattern every two measures, and at 256 measures total that’s 128 unique drum patterns in that one track. The variations are subtle but that’s the point, subtle variations were what I needed. :-)
I haven’t had time to put together a real track with it because I only just worked out MIDI file export this past week, but when I do I’ll be able to put out tracks with 256 unique drum patterns without any effort at all. In fact, I’m planning to do a lot of layering and alternate drum kits for dubby, rhythmic, and/or percussive effects, so 1024 unique, never-repeating drum patterns per track is entirely possible.
This discussion is closed.