“The Dance of Life: The Other Dimension of Time” by Edward T. Hall studies “how people are tied together and yet isolated by hidden threads of rhythm and walls of time.” It contains this fascinating passage describing how humans sync up with each other:
Rhythm is basic to synchrony. This principle is illustrated by a film of children on a playground. Who would think that widely scattered groups of children in a school playground could be in sync. Yet this is precisely the case. One of my students selected as a project an exercise in what can be learned from film. Hiding in an abandoned automobile, which he used as a blind, he filmed children in an adjacent school yard during recess. As he viewed the film, his first impression was the obvious one: a film of children playing in different parts of the school playground. Then — watching the film several times at different speeds, he began to notice one very active little girl who seemed to stand out from the rest. She was all over the place. Concentrating on the girl, my student noticed that whenever she was near a cluster of children the members of that group were in sync not only with each other but with her. Many viewings later, he realized that this girl, with her skipping and dancing and twirling, was actually orchestrating movements of the entire playground! There was something about the pattern of movement which translated into a beat — like a silent movie of people dancing. Furthermore, the beat of this playground was familiar! There was a rhythm he had encountered before. He went to a friend who was a rock music aficionado, and the two of them began to search for the beat. It wasn’t long until the friend reached out to a nearby shelf, took down a cassette and slipped it into a tape deck. That was it! It took a while to synchronize the beginning of the film with the recording — a piece of contemporary rock music — but once started, the entire three and a half minutes of the film clip stayed in sync with the taped music! Not a beat or a frame of the film was out of sync!
...When he showed his film to our seminar, however, even though his explanation of what he had done was perfectly lucid, the members of the seminar had difficulty understanding what had actually happened. One school superintendent spoke of the children as “dancing to the music”; another wanted to know if the children were “humming the tune.” They were voicing the commonly held belief that music is something that is “made up” by a composer, who then passes on “his creation” to others, who, in turn, diffuse it to the larger society. The children were moving, but as with the symphony orchestra, some participants’ parts were at times silent. Eventually all participated and all stayed in sync, but the music was in them. They brought it with them to the playground as a part of shared culture. They had been doing that sort of thing all their lives, beginning with the time they synchronized their movements to their mother’s voice even before they were born.
Related: “Sync” by Steven Strogatz explores “the mysterious synchrony achieved by fireflies that flash in unison by the thousands, and the question of what makes our own body clocks synchronize with night and day and even with one another…The author traces how the isolated and often accidental discoveries of researchers are beginning to gel into the science of synchrony, and he amply illustrates how the laws of mathematics underlie the universe’s uncanny capacity for spontaneous order.” Here’s a review of the book and an interview with Strogatz.
freaktopia
on 25 Apr 07“whenever she was near a cluster of children the members of that group were in sync not only with each other but with her”
really? every group synced up with the girl instead of the girl syncing up with whatever group she was by. pshaw.
it probably matched the music of a current pop song because the girl was probably listening to an ipod.
niuce research. i think vw advertising was bsed on this for a while.
sheesh.
Mike
on 25 Apr 07Hey, can I get a troll cap too?!?
Alexandra
on 25 Apr 07Ooo, this strongly reminds me of a novel – Bellwether by Connie Willis. A very interesting read, though fictional, concerning fads/trends and how they are started…
All things are interconnected…
Beth
on 25 Apr 07I had to get over the initial creepy picture of this guy hiding in an abandoned automobile and filming the children in a school yard…
The observation is fascinating, though.
CJ Curtis
on 25 Apr 07So do they ever say what the music was? Is the video available to view?
Sounds really cool, but the reference to the symphony and at times “certain instruments being silent” makes me think about an individual’s ability to see things from many different perspectives, and how creative the human brain can really be… as opposed to some “cosmic force” that synchronizes all of our actions.
For example, how many of us can see pictures in the clouds? The man in the moon? Actually there are several men in the moon. It just depends on when and where you’re looking.
Mimo
on 25 Apr 07Troll Caps. I thought they died. Great to see them.
Dan
on 25 Apr 07I would also like to know if the video is available. Doesn’t seem to be on youtube. If you’ve ever seen the video, “Pachelbel Rant” on youtube, then you might wonder if the beat of certain music resonates with us as individuals and that’s why it becomes so popular. I’d like to know what song it was because I would imagine that it’s a beat we could find in many other songs as well or even find in nature.
Luke
on 25 Apr 07The position that spontaneous order occurs seems intellectually tenuous. I find that, based on my observations of reality, a more likely position is that things that we see as chaotic which become ordered were ordered to begin with.
Spontaneous order seems, to me, like an illogical phrase to use with what I experientially know about the universe. Things don’t just ‘spontaneously’ become ordered…they are made that way.
Let’s just say that IF a being of infinite characteristics were to have created the universe from nothing, with an intention of sustaining the existence of the creation for the glory of itself, then wouldn’t order necessarily have to permeate throughout the creation since chaos and disorder is less sustainable?
What does this mean for the software design and development community? Maybe someone should start a blog that’s not about design philosophy, but rather about philosophy for designers.
(I know that most reading here would appreciate if SvN was not tainted with inane philosophical bickering, so if you feel the need to do some intellectual discourse (or flaming): lukedary at hotmail dot com)
joshua
on 25 Apr 07I think the last sentence of the quote “they synchronized their movements to their mother’s voice even before they were born,” points to an interesting place to start investigating human synchronicities. Granted, I am assuming that the children on the playground share English as a common language, and that the linguistic assertion that our language shapes our thinking is true. If so, it does not seem like a conceptual leap to suggest that the children’s movement may have a relationship to iambs and trochees, to the meter and musicality inherent in English. And it is no surprise that Rock music, whose genesis is rooted in English speaking countries, would sync to that movement.
I’d be deeply curious to know whether a playground in Ghana or Thailand would exhibit a different kind of rhythm, one tied to the meter of those children’s native tongue.
(Are bi-lingual people better dancers?!)
Fascinating stuff!
Ty Graham
on 25 Apr 07Topics like this are becoming more common lately, even in scientific media. I saw an article describing the sun as an instrument with actual tones that can be listened to which is unique to each star. They can tell the age of the star by the pitch or sound of the tone like listening to a drum’s beat. If a star can sync to some unseen order why can’t we since we’re made from stars? The beauty of our mind is that we can distinguish and choose what to believe. It’s only a matter of time science proves that religion is just another way of saying the same scientific discoveries yet to be uncovered. Life is synchronized on a daily basis, plants wrap lassos around trees, lay still but plan dinner traps. Are we not greater than a plant? One of these days, we’ll probably tap into the Human OS—but for now, we’re still trying to figure out the bits of code. It’s like we’re starting backwards and trying to figure out the beginning. Let’s decompile our species and make sense of how we tick. Perhaps when we finally know how we operate, we could make this world and our relationships with each other, more human. I love free thinkers who rebel against the norm. Cheers to you, great stuff!
skye
on 30 Apr 07I really enjoy Edward Hall’s research and writing. I was first exposed to this book (my favorite of his) in my Introduction to Cultural Anthropology class. It was due to this book, as well as a few others, that I decided to major in Cultural Anthropology. He inspired me to look deeper into the way people live their lives. I often referred to this book when I needed to overcome hurdles while conducting my own ethnographic fieldwork.
This discussion is closed.